Wingman / Compare
CompareEOR, direct hire or payroll software: which fits a micro business?
All three work. The difference is who carries the employer's legal and filing duties, and how much of that admin lands on you.
Last reviewed 2026-11-15. Estimates only, not a quote or advice.
Side by side
| Topic | Hire directly | Payroll software or service | Employer of record (Wingman) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal employer | Your business | Your business | Elitez Aviation Pte. Ltd. |
| CPF and SDL submission | You, or your adviser | Often prepared by the tool, you remain responsible | Elitez |
| WICA and health cover | You arrange separately | You arrange separately | Group cover arranged (premiums at cost) |
| IR8A | You file | Tool may prepare it, you file | Elitez files |
| Employment contract with | Your business | Your business | Elitez Aviation Pte. Ltd. |
| Best when | You already have HR and finance capacity | You want tooling and still own the compliance | You want to hire without running payroll and compliance yourself |
This table compares categories, not named products. Features and fees vary by provider, so check the specifics of any option you are considering.
Paying payroll by card: Wingman vs CardUp and ipaymy
| Topic | CardUp (card-payment platform) | ipaymy (card-payment platform) | Wingman |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Lets you pay bills, including payroll, with a credit card | Lets you pay bills, including salaries, with a credit card | Employer of record: we employ your Singapore staff and run payroll, CPF, WICA and IR8A |
| Card fee | 2.9% standard on Singapore-issued cards, 3.3% on overseas cards; code BIZPAY235 lowers payroll to 2.35% on Singapore Visa until 31 Jan 2027 | 2.85% on Singapore Mastercard, 2.95% on Singapore Visa; 3.35% to 3.95% on overseas cards | 0.99% in year 1, 1.79% from year 2; 0.99% for both years on a 2-year agreement |
| Fee per mile at 1.6 miles per S$1 | About 1.8 cents a mile at 2.9% | About 1.8 cents a mile at 2.85% | About 0.6 cents a mile at 0.99%; about 1.1 cents at 1.79% |
| Payroll | Money lands in your company bank account; you still pay staff, run payroll and file CPF yourself | Pays your staff, or your company account, from your card; you still run payroll and file CPF yourself | We pay your staff, remit CPF and SDL, and file IR8A |
| Employer duties | None. It is a payments service | None. It is a payments service | Elitez Aviation Pte. Ltd. is the legal employer of your Singapore Citizen and PR staff |
| Service fee | Card fee only | Card fee only | S$29 per employee per month for 1 to 5 employees, plus the card fee |
| Best when | You want to move an existing bill onto a card | You already run payroll and want to put salaries on a card | You want to hire without running payroll and compliance, and still earn miles |
How to read this. CardUp and ipaymy are payment platforms, not employers, so the like-for-like number is the card fee. On a S$9,000 monthly card payment, CardUp's 2.9% is about S$261 a month, ipaymy's published local rates of 2.85% to 2.95% come to about S$257 to S$266, and our 0.99% is about S$89 in the first year (about S$161 at 1.79% from year 2, unless you sign for 2 years). Our S$29 fee pays for the employer work CardUp and ipaymy do not do. If either provider quotes you a promo code the gap narrows, so compare the rate you are actually offered. Miles depend on your card and issuer; check its terms.
Sources checked 10 Nov 2026: CardUp pricing (2.9% standard, 3.3% overseas cards), Suitesmile on the June 2026 promo changes, CardUp on how payroll payments work and CardUp Business, which lists no employer-of-record or CPF service; ipaymy fees (2.85% local Mastercard, 2.95% local Visa, dated 24 Sep 2026) and ipaymy salary payments, which describe payment only, with no CPF, payroll or IR8A service. Rates change; confirm with each provider.
When an EOR is not the right fit
- You need a foreign work pass sponsored (EP, S Pass, WP). That is not part of our current offer
- You have more than five employees and want self-serve pricing
- You want to be the named employer on every contract
Frequently asked questions
Is an EOR cheaper than hiring directly?
Does an EOR replace my accountant?
How does Wingman compare with CardUp?
How does Wingman compare with ipaymy?
Does an EOR work for foreign hires?
Ready to hire without the payroll workload?
Tell us your headcount and we will confirm fit and next steps. 12-month or 2-year agreement, no setup fee.